Paralyzed By Hope: The Maria Bamford Story Review - Judd Apatow's Essential Sundance Portrait of a Singular Comic

1 week ago 18

Paralyzed_by_Hope_The_Maria_Bamford_Story-Still_1

Published 14 minutes ago

Gregory Nussen is the Lead Film Critic for Screen Rant. They have previously written for Deadline Hollywood, Slant Magazine, Backstage and Salon. Other bylines: In Review Online, Vague Visages, Bright Lights Film Journal, The Servant, The Harbour Journal, Boing Boing Knock-LA & IfNotNow's Medium. They were the recipient of the 2022 New York Film Critics Circle Graduate Prize in Criticism, and are a proud member of GALECA, the Society of LGBTQ Entertainment Critics. They co-host the Great British Baking Podcast. Gregory also has a robust performance career: their most recent solo performance, QFWFQ, was nominated for five awards, winning Best Solo Theatre at the Hollywood Fringe Festival in 2025.

Maria Bamford has been one of the most prolific and most original voices in comedy of the last three decades, and yet she is still, at 55 years old, talked about like she's a breakout candidate. When her criminally under-watched Netflix series Lady Dynamite debuted, it was written about as if the Minnesota-born comic was plucked from the depths of the obscure by Arrested Development creator Mitchell Hurwitz. But she's been around for a long time, and Paralyzed by Hope: The Maria Bamford Story is an essential doc that reveals the origins of her singular voice with exceeding warmth and vulnerability.

Directors Judd Apatow and Neil Berkeley approach Bamford's life story with relatively simple methods, but, with editor James Leche, the trio beautifully curates Bamford's magnitude of on-stage work such that clear lines are drawn between the comic's real-life experiences and their exploitation for gold. Starting in Minneapolis in 1994, when Bamford was still doing more experimental performance art work with a violin in tow, till her latest exploits doing 8 AM sets at Public Displays of Altadena (PDA), an alt-clown theater which burned in the Eaton Fires in January of 2024, Paralyzed by Hope is an all-encompassing primer on a wholly original artist.

Paralyzed By Hope Suggests That Maria Bamford's Career Is Thanks To Her Struggle

Lady Dynamite Maria Bamford Netflix Finale Review

One of the film's many talking heads is Conan O'Brien, who, early on, remarks on the fact that Bamford is the open-wound platonic ideal that other comics purport to be. Which is to say that all of her anxieties, her debilitating obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), her suicidal ideation, her brushes with extreme debt and eating disorders, are all nakedly out in the open. If all comics deal with some form of anxiety as a baseline, says Conan, it's Bamford that acts like "a lobster" whose shell has been ripped off and cannot help but feel everything.

That "everything" has influenced the comic's every waking moment as well as her on-stage persona and the popular impression of her as a continuous character. The signature quality of her natural voice, lilted with midwestern nice and pitched high and tinny, makes her sound like almost like a children's show host. Her fashion is eccentric and vibrant, and these days she looks a bit like a younger version of The Great British Baking Show host Prue Leith, bedazzled eyeglasses and all.

But underneath that facade and her massive smile is a woman who has continuously battled mental health, leading her to be interred at a psych ward and a long-time dependence on PROzac and other mood stabilizers. Though the drugs have given her a muscle shake in recent years, they have also saved her life. "I'm not so much depressed as paralyzed by hope," Bamford says on stage, and truer words have ne'er been spoke by someone who, sometimes literally, has to muscle her way onto the stage.

She's tenacious and strong, but even if she wasn't, "weakness if the brand," as she jokes. There's power in failure.

It's one of those miracles of evolution that sometimes people with the biggest roadblocks to public success find that, perhaps ironically, being in front of people is what can save their life. Bamford found early that performance was a way to connect with people while still feeling safe, and, through her act and Lady Dynamite, she connects best by inhabiting the bizarre comic irony of mental health. Few comics are as honest as Bamford; even less as funny about it as she continues to be.

But getting here was clearly a big journey. Bamford's consistent battle with death has influenced her work even since childhood when, Harold & Maude-like, she would stage her own death "for fun," slathering herself in ketchup or fake overdosing on Tums. "We didn't get it," her dad freely admits. Her mother, a devout Christian, inadvertently fed Bamford's anxieties by telling her that she looked "mentally ill" when she didn't apply makeup. Bamford has the last laugh, always, with all of her family members becoming regular characters in her stand-up.

Today, Bamford continues to work consistently, and, miraculously, her home with her husband in Altadena survived the fires. If it wasn't already obvious through the testimony of peers like Zach Galifianakis, Patton Oswalt, Natasha Leggero and Stephen Colbert, we're extremely lucky that she continues to beat the odds. She's tenacious and strong, but even if she wasn't, "weakness if the brand," as she jokes. There's power in failure.